Notes on
How Babies Talk: The Mgic and Mystery of Language in the First Three Years of LifeRoberta Michnick Golinkoff and Kathy Hirsh-Pasek, 1999
Read-skimmed November-December 2006
The book discusses how children learn to speak, from before birth to three years old. Describes current research in the field, with many examples of experiments that show that children do or do not understand different things at different points in their growth.
It’s all plainly described, in jargon-free language, but I had a hard time focussing and reading this book. I slogged through the first seventy pages before giving up and skimming the rest (which was, admittedly, more interesting).
Too bad I couldn’t read it, since there was lots of interesting content. It really is amazing that a person can learn to speak in three years, given that you start from scratch in so many ways. I mean, you don’t even know what objects are when you’re born. Somehow they are able to listen to uninterrupted syllable streams and eventually be able to decode them and create their own.
I’m not sure why I found it so hard to read. One thing that hurt was that too many experiments were discussed. The treatment of each was fine: here’s what the researcher was trying to figure out; there’s the technique; there’s the results. Good scientific method all around. But it took too much energy to read that critically – did the experiment really prove what it was supposed to, or were there better, alternate, explanations? Was the design correct? That took too much thinking; not that there was enough detail given to really answer those questions anyways. The experiments were certainly interesting and in some cases ingenious, but I would have preferred leaving them out.
Some interesting points:
At all stages of growth, children understand much much more than they can communicate. Newborns can make out their parents voices, and they can tell the difference between their parents’ language and other language. It’s not long before they recognize their own name.
There is a “vocabulary spurt” that usually happens around eighteen months. Here’s an experiment to do with your child. Place two objects on the table, one of which is recognizable by the child (so that you can ask for it by name), and one which isn’t. Ask for the non-recognizable object by name. Before the vocabulary spurt, the child doesn’t know what you’re talking about, and can’t figure it out. After the spurt, the child has the logic to know that it’s not the object he/she knows about, so it must be the other one. Not only does the child now give you the right object, but he/she has incidentally learned the name of that object.
Which sounds can be pronounced when:
p, m, h, n, w, b | first two years |
k, g, d, t | two – four years |
r, l | three – six years |
f, y | 2.5 – 4 years |
ch, sh, z, j, v | 3.5 – 8 years |
There were some very interesting items on class-based differences in children's environments, but I will put those in the following post.